Trading courses and fake mentors: from a cheap course to an expensive trap
Trading education is legal, and some of it is honest. The scam version sells a dream of freedom, shows a rich lifestyle, charges for a course and then moves you up: a mentoring tier, a signal group, a broker, a managed account. Each step costs more and the profit is mainly made by the seller.
Red flags
- The mentor shows cars, watches and holidays, but no audited or independent track record.
- Earnings claims are made in ads, screenshots or testimonials, with no mention of how many students lose money.
- A cheap or free webinar leads to a pitch for a premium program priced in thousands, with a deadline or 'only five places left'.
- You are told to open an account with a particular broker, often one unknown or unregulated, using the mentor's link.
- Course advisers are paid on commission but call themselves education counsellors or coaches.
- You are offered financing for the course by a loan or a payment plan.
- The mentor or an 'assistant' offers to trade for you or asks for access to your trading account.
- Questions or complaints are met with blocking, silence or a contract clause that forbids bad reviews.
- The mentor is not on the register of the regulator in your country, but gives investment advice or recommendations.
How it works step by step
The first step is attention. A person on social media posts short videos of a rich life that supposedly comes from trading. Some are real traders who sell courses honestly. Others show money that is borrowed, rented or from the course sales themselves. The link goes to a free lesson or a low-priced course, often a few hundred pounds, dollars or euros.
The second step is the upsell. The basic course is only an introduction. The real secret, you are told, is in the advanced programme, the private group or one-to-one mentoring. A salesperson calls, praises your progress and says a special price ends today. The FTC described this model in its case against Online Trading Academy: it alleged that the company made unsupported promises of big profits from its investment training programmes, and according to its complaint and the company's own data, most customers lost money rather than earning it. Many students paid thousands of dollars and some took out loans.
The third step is the platform. The mentor tells students to trade with a certain broker or crypto platform, often because he earns commission on the account, and in worse cases because the 'broker' is a fake. A public account of one victim describes a 997 dollar mentor fee, then a Telegram group of over 200 people and a polished trading platform. Early trades looked good. The mentor said that a higher balance would unlock a 'managed VIP tier', and in the end the platform asked for a 10,000 dollar 'security deposit' to unlock withdrawals.
The last step is the loss: the student blames themselves, and the mentor says that the strategy failed because it was not followed. Some people are then offered 'loss recovery' or account management, the same pattern described in the recovery scam guide on this site.
What the mentors say
These lines come from regulators' cases and from victims' accounts on public forums:
- I turned 500 dollars into 50,000 in three months. My system is simple and anybody can copy it.
- The free course shows only 10 percent. The VIP mentoring gives you the entry points I use myself.
- Spots close tonight. After that the price doubles.
- Do not use your own broker. Use my partner broker, because it gives us direct signals and lower spreads.
- Your account is too small for the signals to work. Top it up to 5,000 and I will add you to the managed tier.
- If you cannot pay in one go, we have a financing partner. Your first profits will cover the instalments.
- Losing trades are normal. If you lost, you did not follow the rules, so I cannot refund.
Why it works
The offer matches a strong wish for independence and a way out of salary work, and social media gives it a face. Selling the course is the business, not trading. The more students believe, the more the seller earns, whether the student wins or not. As an FCA financial crime official has put it when describing illegal finfluencer promotions, whether people win or lose, the promoter gets paid anyway.
Sunk cost does the rest. A student who has paid 3,000 for a course finds it hard to stop, so the 10,000 programme looks like a way to make the first payment useful. Fake testimonials, a closed chat in which everyone cheers and a sales team using scripts create the pressure.
Many mentors also give personal investment recommendations without any licence, which is exactly what regulators say they should not do.
Real numbers
In September 2020 the FTC announced a settlement with Online Trading Academy, its founder and others. The order banned unsupported earnings claims and clauses that limit consumer reviews, required debt forgiveness on loans that financed the training for thousands of customers, and carried a large monetary judgment, partly suspended because the defendants could not pay. The founder had to pay at least 8.3 million dollars.
In Australia the Federal Court found that a social media trader had carried on a financial services business without a licence by running share-trading courses and seminars and selling subscriptions to a private chat, and in June 2025 ASIC issued warning notices to 18 so-called finfluencers. In April 2026 the UK FCA led a week of action with 17 other regulators: it identified 1,267 illegal financial adverts on Meta platforms that reached at least 2.3 million UK accounts, and 66 percent came from firms or people already on its Warning List. The FCA issued 2,329 warnings about unauthorised or possibly scam firms and individuals in 2025.
What to do if it happened to you
Stop paying and do not take a loan to 'complete' the programme. Save the sales page, contract, invoices, chats, ads and testimonials, and any promises of income. If you paid by card, ask your card company about a chargeback, as paying for a service that was misrepresented may entitle you to a refund. If you have a loan, contact the lender in writing and say you dispute the contract, because the FTC case shows that debt can be cancelled in some cases.
Check whether the mentor or the broker is authorised, using the register of your regulator. Report unlicensed advice to the regulator: in the UK the FCA, in Australia ASIC, in the US the SEC, CFTC or FTC and your state securities office, in other countries your national authority. If your money went to a trading platform through the mentor, treat it as an investment scam: see the guides about fake trading apps and withdrawal fee demands on this site.
Do not accept offers to recover your course money for an advance fee.
How to protect yourself
Ask for an audited, independent record of results, and for the number of students who made money, not for testimonials. Check who is behind the course in a regulator's register, and whether the seller is allowed to give personal advice. Be wary if the first course leads only to a more expensive one.
Never open an account with a broker only because a mentor tells you to, and never give anyone trading access to your account or your password. Learn from free, neutral sources, such as your regulator's investor education pages, before paying anyone. Most retail day traders lose money, and no course changes that arithmetic.
Questions people ask
Are all trading courses scams?
No. Some education is honest and focuses on risk and basic knowledge. The warning signs are promises of income, pressure to buy higher tiers, unlicensed personal advice and a push to use a specific broker.
Is it legal for a mentor to tell me what to buy?
In many countries, personal recommendations are regulated advice and need a licence. In Australia the Federal Court found one trader had run an unlicensed financial services business through courses and a paid chat. Check the register in your country.
Can I get a refund for a trading course?
Sometimes. You can ask the seller, use a card chargeback or a loan dispute, and complain to a consumer or financial regulator. Refunds depend on the contract and the country, so act quickly and keep evidence.
My mentor wants me to deposit with his broker. Is that a red flag?
Yes. The mentor may earn commission, or the broker may be fake. Check the broker's licence in the register of a recognised regulator before depositing, and test a withdrawal.
My mentor offers to trade my account for a share of profits. Is that safe?
No. Managing money for others usually requires a licence, and giving access can lead to losses or theft. See the guide on copy trading and managed accounts on this site.
Check a website
Where to report
Sources
FTC: Online Trading Academy settles charges over deceptive money-making claims (2020) · UK FCA: global action to stop illegal finfluencers (April 2026) · ASIC: Federal Court findings against a social media finfluencer (2022) · ASIC: warning notices to 18 finfluencers in a global week of action (2025)