Precious metals, diamonds, wine and carbon credits: scams that sell 'real' assets
Scammers sell things people believe are safe: gold, silver, investment diamonds, fine wine, carbon credits or rare commodities. The asset may not exist, may be stored where you cannot check it, or may be worth far less than you paid. A separate scam makes victims buy gold themselves and hand it to a courier.
Red flags
- A cold call, an ad or a seminar offers a limited chance to buy gold, diamonds, wine or carbon credits now, before a price jump.
- You are told that the price is guaranteed to rise, and that big investors are already buying.
- You pay only part of the price and a company arranges a loan for the rest, a form of leveraged buying.
- The company promises to store the asset for you, but does not name the vault, or says it is stored overseas.
- The seller says it is not regulated or not covered by a compensation scheme, or the firm cannot show a licence.
- Prices are far above market, and you cannot find the same asset sold by independent dealers.
- You are asked to move savings or retirement money to buy metal, or told to hand over cash or gold to an 'agent'.
- Certificates and reports come from the seller's own laboratory, valuer or website, not independent ones.
- You cannot sell back easily, and the buyback price is far below what you paid.
How it works step by step
Two families of scams use the same assets. In the first, an investment seller offers metals, diamonds, wine or carbon credits as a profitable and safe place for savings. In the second, a fake official or bank officer tells the victim that their money is in danger, and tells them to convert savings into gold, then hand it to a courier.
In the investment version, the CFTC describes a typical pattern with precious metals. A salesperson calls, sells the idea of profit from news that everyone already knows, claims credibility and urgency, and may use lines such as 'there are only two units left' or 'half-price commission if you buy today'. The buyer pays only 15 to 25 percent of the price, and the company arranges a loan for the rest. Then metal is supposedly stored in a vault or abroad. Victims later find that the money was never used to buy metal, that interest on the loan was invented, or that storage fees were charged for metal that was not there.
The UK FCA describes carbon credit scams in a similar way: contact is mainly unsolicited, with offers of certificates or a share in a green project, presented as a booming market. Many investors say they cannot sell their credits, and carbon credits are not regulated by the FCA, so there is no compensation scheme or ombudsman. Diamonds, wine and rare commodities follow the same logic: the object is hard for a layman to value, the seller supplies the certificate and the price, and the buyer cannot resell at that price.
In the courier version, victims are told that their accounts are compromised and that a government agent or bank officer will protect their money. They are told to buy gold bars, sometimes from legitimate dealers, and give them to a courier who arrives at their home. The FBI says the government will never ask people to buy gold or other precious metals.
The sales lines
From regulators' fraud notes and victims' stories:
- This gold purchase will rise twice as fast as your current investments, and the price is guaranteed for this week only.
- You only put down 20 percent. We lend the rest, and we keep the metal safe in our vault in Switzerland.
- These investment diamonds are certified by our own gemologist, and they gain 12 percent every year.
- Fine wine from this vintage is sold out. We can offer you a place in a barrel allocation if you transfer today.
- Carbon credits are the next big market. Governments will force companies to buy them at much higher prices.
- Your bank account is not safe. Convert your savings to gold bars and a federal courier will secure them.
Why it works
Hard assets feel real. Gold has centuries of trust, and wine and diamonds are used in luxury. The seller uses that trust, then adds a story: inflation, a currency crisis, a green boom. The victim's fear of losing savings in a bank is a strong tool for the courier scams too.
The details are hard to verify. A buyer cannot test a diamond's grade, a barrel of wine in a warehouse or an offshore carbon project. Sellers can set the price and the resale market. Pressure and 'limited supply' stop people from asking an independent dealer.
Regulation is often weaker. Land, wine, carbon credits and physical metal may not fall under financial services law, so investors may lose access to a regulator, a compensation fund or an ombudsman.
Real numbers
The FTC's August 2025 study of older adults found that gold was written in as the payment method or mentioned in the narrative in about 5 percent of reports of losses of 10,000 dollars or more, and in about 21 percent of reports of losses over 100,000 dollars. FBI Boston said the FBI had documented at least 1,737 cases nationally between 2023 and May 2025 in which a courier collected bulk cash or gold bars, with losses of about 186.3 million dollars, and that about 98 percent of the Boston-area losses were reported by people over 60. The FBI noted that the real total is probably higher.
In the UK, Action Fraud reported that more than 1,500 people lost a total of 24 million pounds to a single carbon credit scam, and the FCA says carbon credits are not regulated by it. The CFTC's advice states that people who buy from fraudulent precious metals firms usually lose all or a large part of their investment.
What to do if it happened to you
If you handed gold or cash to a courier, call the police and the FBI or your national police at once and give the description of the courier, vehicle and time, as well as phone numbers. Contact the dealer and your bank. Quick reports sometimes lead to arrests of couriers. In the US use ic3.gov and the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
If you bought an asset through a firm, stop paying fees and loan instalments, take photographs and copies of all contracts, certificates and storage documents, and ask an independent expert to value the item. Report to the regulator that covers commodities or investment in your country, in the US the CFTC and the state securities office, in the UK the FCA, Report Fraud and Trading Standards. If you paid by card or transfer, tell your bank. Be wary of recovery firms offering to get the money back for an advance fee.
How to protect yourself
Never buy a metal, gem, wine or credit from a stranger who contacts you. Compare the price with independent dealers and the spot price, and expect the dealer's margin to be visible. Ask who holds the asset, where, and who audits it. Do not buy with a loan arranged by the seller.
Do not move savings because a caller says they are in danger. No government agent or bank will ask you to buy gold or give it to a courier. If you want exposure to metals, think about regulated funds or established dealers, with full written terms.
Questions people ask
Is investing in gold a scam?
No. Gold can be bought from reputable dealers or through regulated funds. The scams involve pressure sales, huge markups, leveraged deals with a stored metal you cannot verify, or tricks that make you hand gold to a stranger.
What is the gold courier scam?
A caller pretends to be a bank or a government agent, says your money is at risk, and tells you to buy gold and give it to a courier for safekeeping. The FBI says the government will never ask people to buy gold or other precious metals.
Are investment diamonds or fine wine safe?
They are hard to value and hard to resell at the price you paid. Warnings from regulators in several countries note overpriced stones, wine that does not exist, and certificates issued by the seller. Get independent valuation first.
Are carbon credit investments regulated?
In the UK the FCA says carbon credits are not regulated by it, so there is no access to the compensation scheme or the ombudsman, and many investors say they cannot sell their credits. Check your own country's rules.
Can I recover money after buying fake metal?
Sometimes, through the police, a regulator's case, a chargeback or a court. Success depends on speed and evidence. Do not pay anyone who promises recovery in return for an advance fee.
Check a website
Where to report
Sources
CFTC fraud advisory: precious metals fraud · CFTC customer advisory: 10 things to ask before buying physical gold, silver or other metals · FBI Boston: warning on gold bar and bulk cash courier scams · FTC Data Spotlight: False alarm, real scam (August 2025) · UK FCA ScamSmart: carbon credit scams · Action Fraud: investors warned over 24 million pound carbon credit scam