Binary options scams: the all-or-nothing bet that was rigged
A binary option is a yes or no bet on a price, with a fixed payout or total loss. Even a fair one loses money on average, and many online platforms were not fair: phone brokers pushed deposits, withdrawals were blocked, and some software was said to change results. Binary options were banned for retail clients in the EU in 2018.
Red flags
- A broker, 'account manager' or 'analyst' phones you again and again and urges larger deposits.
- The platform advertises average returns above what the payout structure can give, or says you cannot lose.
- You receive a 'bonus' that must be traded many times before you can withdraw anything.
- The firm asks for copies of your card, passport or driving licence and your card details, and is not in a regulator's register.
- Withdrawal requests are cancelled, delayed, ignored, or answered with a request for more money.
- Trades that were winning end up as losses, or the platform freezes at the last seconds.
- The product is sold under another name, such as digital options, fixed-time trades, turbo options or prediction contracts, by a firm outside your country.
- The firm contacted you after you left your details on a celebrity ad or fake news page.
How it works step by step
A binary option pays a fixed amount, or nothing, depending on a simple outcome, such as whether a currency will be above a level in 60 seconds. The CFTC and the SEC explain the maths in their alert: if a win pays 50 percent and a loss costs nearly the entire stake, the expected return is negative, so on average customers lose.
The scam begins with an ad or a lead form. A phone broker calls, friendly and persistent, and takes a first deposit of a few hundred. The platform shows early wins. The broker then pushes for a larger deposit, offering a bonus, a personal mentor or access to a 'special signal'.
The US regulators list three kinds of complaints. First, platforms refuse to credit accounts or reimburse money: after the first deposit, customers are pushed to deposit more, and when they ask to withdraw, requests are cancelled, delayed or ignored. Second, identity theft: the platform collects copies of cards and driving licences. Third, software manipulation: the regulators said some firms allegedly altered the software so that, when a trade was winning, the countdown to expiry was extended until the trade became a loss.
European police have seen the same business at scale. In 2021, with Europol and Eurojust support, authorities in Germany, Bulgaria, Cyprus, the Netherlands and Ukraine took down a network that ran call centres in Bulgaria, Cyprus and Ukraine with German-speaking operators, offering binary options on a professional-looking site. Losses were at least 15 million euros, and investigators said the total could reach about 500 million euros.
The phrases to know
From regulator alerts and victims' complaints on public forums:
- This is a risk-free trade. The platform insures your deposit with a 15 percent return even if you lose.
- I am your personal analyst. Follow my signal this minute, double your stake.
- Your bonus is 100 percent, but you must trade it 40 times before withdrawal.
- To process your withdrawal we need a photo of your card front and back and a selfie with your passport.
- Your withdrawal is pending compliance. Deposit 10 percent to confirm that the account is yours.
- The market was strange today. This was an unexpected event, and nobody could foresee it.
Why it works
The product is simple to explain. Anyone can understand 'up or down', so it feels easier than normal trading. Short expiry times make it feel like a game, with fast wins that give a rush. The brokers sell excitement and then confidence, so the client does not check the maths.
The business was also built to lose clients. Because the platform is the opposite side of the bet, its profit is the client's loss. That is a conflict of interest, which is why ESMA said the products have a structurally negative expected return and why the EU, and later others, stopped selling them to retail clients.
Finally, the phone is the key. A friendly broker who calls every day builds a relationship, and a client who has already lost money wants to win it back.
Real numbers
ESMA announced a prohibition on marketing, distribution and sale of binary options to retail investors in the EU on 27 March 2018, after national regulators found consistent losses on retail clients' accounts. The UK FCA introduced a permanent ban for retail consumers in 2019. Israel, home to many of the platforms, banned the sale of binary options to Israeli residents in 2016 and passed a law in October 2017 that forbids Israeli firms to sell them abroad.
In the United States, the SEC filed a case in 2013 against Banc de Binary for offering and selling binary options to US investors without registering them as required, and the CFTC and SEC issued a joint alert on binary option fraud. In Europe, investigators said in 2021 that a single network could be responsible for about 500 million euros in estimated total fraud, with at least 15 million euros established at the time of the takedown.
What to do if it happened to you
Stop depositing, even if the broker says the next deposit will unlock your money. Save account statements, chats, call recordings if you made them, the names and numbers of the 'brokers', the payment receipts and the website address. If you paid by card, ask your bank for a chargeback quickly, because time limits apply, and tell it if you also gave your card photos or ID.
Report to the financial regulator and the police in your country, and to the regulator of the country where the firm says it is based. In the US use the CFTC, the SEC and ic3.gov, in the UK the FCA and Report Fraud, in the EU your national authority. Check the regulator's warning list. Watch your credit and your accounts for misuse of your ID and consider freezing credit or changing your card.
Be careful with recovery offers. Many people who lost on binary options are later approached by firms that promise to get the money back for an advance fee. This is a known second scam.
How to protect yourself
In the EU and the UK, a firm that offers binary options to retail clients is already breaking the ban, so treat it as a scam. Elsewhere, check the firm in a regulator's register, and do not trade with firms that call you, promise profit or ask for photos of your card.
If you want to take a market view, use regulated instruments with clear rules, and read the risk statement. Never send ID or card images to a trading site that you cannot verify.
Questions people ask
Are binary options illegal?
For retail clients they are banned in the EU since 2018 and in the UK since 2019. In the US they can be offered only on regulated exchanges, and most online platforms were not. Rules differ by country.
Is all binary options trading a scam?
Not every platform cheated, but the product is structured so that clients lose on average, and regulators found widespread fraud. Many offers have been renamed as other 'fixed-time' products.
My binary options broker will not let me withdraw. What now?
Save the evidence, ask for the written reason, and file a chargeback request if you paid by card. Report to the regulator and the police. Do not pay a fee to release your balance.
Can I get my money back from a binary options broker?
Sometimes a part, through a chargeback, a regulator's action, a court or compensation in an enforcement case. The chance is higher when you act within weeks. Avoid recovery firms that charge upfront.
I sent a copy of my card and ID to a binary options site. Is that dangerous?
Yes. The US regulators list identity theft as one of the complaints. Tell your bank, replace the card, watch your accounts and credit, and consider an identity theft report in your country.
Check a website
Where to report
Sources
CFTC and SEC investor alert: binary options and fraud · ESMA: prohibits binary options and restricts CFDs for retail investors (2018) · Eurojust: fraudulent German online investment platform taken down (2021) · Europol: network selling fake financial services online taken down · SEC: 2013 case concerning unregistered binary options offers